Breaking Down Gender Norms
How I Met
Your mother is heading into the end of their iconic run as one of the most
popular television programs on CBS. It has been a long run for the television series, which has aired nine
total seasons. The show has revolved around the main protagonist Ted
Mosby and his friends living in New York City, searching for Ted’s future wife,
and mother of his kids. The show has had
great success due to the hilarious story plots, its evolving characters, and
the flexibility between masculine and feminine gender roles intertwined with
the main character Ted Mosby. For
example in season 8 episode 24 Ted brings his friend Lily to his newly
renovated house, and shows her all of the construction work he has done by
himself. The scene presents Ted showing
his masculine side by rebuilding the house, but just a few seconds later he
relates himself to Ryan Gosling in the Notebook. A movie few men would ever say they have
seen. It’s this flexibility of gender roles
that breaks down what is considered normal ways of acting as either masculine
or feminine in society.
Ted Mosby by all means is considered
one of the nicest guys on television these days. In the show he parades around looking for his
one true love, Ted is not interested in meaningless relationships like many
male characters on television today.
Many of Ted’s characteristics in show could be described as female
gender traits. He is a hopeless
romantic, genuine nice guy, and he truly wants to settle down with a
family. In society if a male was
displaying these characteristics the first thought would be that he is metro-sexual, gay, or that he is quite frankly not a real man. How I Met Your Mother has had great success
with disobeying these social norms, because it allows men, and women to
both relate to the character, and strive to understand that you don’t have to
follow the social norms of being purely male, or female.
Androgyny is an individual that
displays balanced levels of characteristics of both masculinity and femininity
(Cobb, Walsh & Priest, pg.83, 2009).Ted is a prime example of this throughout
the series. He is a man who can go out
and do manly things with his friends like going to a strip club, getting into a
bar fight, and drinking beers with the boys.
Ted can also talk about his feelings and be a hopeless romantic. Most
of the comedy in the show is revolved around Ted showing gender flexibility,
and in some ways how society looks at gender flexibility.
Throughout the series Ted has experienced
backlash and praise over his gender diversity.
Gender diversity is when ones preferences and self-expression fall
outside the commonly understood gender roles.
Gender diversity is a normal part of human expression, and has been
recorded over history (Understanding Gender).
Gender diversity has been recorded in all cultures, and it still is seen
as being a controversial trait to have in society. In the show Ted has been falsely identified
as being gay, in more than one occasion.
The characteristics of his personality have drawn such conclusions, due
to him portraying more feminine traits than normal male gender traits. In one scene Robin introduces her new
boyfriend Don to the gang. Robin hasn't told
Don she used to have a relationship with Ted.
While Ted and the Don are talking about relationships Don asks Ted how
he would feel if Ted’s boyfriend hung out with one his exes. Ted is utterly shocked
by hearing the allegations that he is in fact gay, but then the scene jumps to
flashbacks of Ted acting in a feminine manner.
This scene represents how many people jump to conclusions about someone’s
sexual identity, because they might not be acting in the perception of gender
roles that accompanies their biological sex.
Where is written that you have to be purely masculine or feminine? Media and television have helped push these
social norms with early television programs, such as Queer eye for the Straight
guy, and the Man Show, which presented what society, thought of as gay men, and
straight men. These shows had no neutral
ground for both gender types. You were
either a manly man, or a flamboyant homosexual.
Ted Mosby is one of the first characters on television that showed it was
possible for someone to show traits of both genders.
One personality trait that presents
Ted as being feminine and in some cases has been the one trait many people see
as annoying is his overly romantic personality.
Ted is in search of his true love in every episode of the show. This personality is considered to be portraying
how women feel about relationships in today’s society. Men are not seen as being romantic people,
and many of Teds portrayals of romantic behavior are considered to be actions
of females. Nick Mayer states “Ted is
not even close to what the public and the media outlets view as a socially
acceptable role of a male looking for a relationship”. From what it seems, society has come to the
consensus that chivalry is dead. Men are
not supposed to plan romantic evenings for their dates, and take that extra
step to going beyond the social norms of society. Ted offers a detailed example of how men can
still be romantic, and how that trait can be used successfully in today’s
society. One example of Ted displaying
his feminine romantic side is when he steals the blue French horn for Robin,
and presents it to her on their first date.
Ted unfortunately ruins the date when he tells her he loves her, but the
episode shows that men can be romantic and there’s no problem with that. Women are considered to be hopeless romantics
that fall in love at a drop of a hat. The
episode turns that gender norm upside down with Ted being the one who instantly
falls in love and has Robin being the one who gets freaked out by Ted’s
revelation. If a man wants to do nice
things for the women he is trying to be with, then why does society and people in
their life consider the act as being girly or unmanly? Ted Mosby offers men the perception that
having female gender traits is not a bad thing.
Gender norms are just ideas that people have learned since they were
kids. The character of Ted expresses that’s
it better to be true to yourself than follow the societal norms of the world.
Society has been driven on what
perceptions of gender roles should be between men and women. How I met Your Mother is great example of
what gender flexibility looks like and how it can be viewed in today’s
society. Ted Mosby’s personality offers
an insight in of how you can express both gender roles in today’s society, and how
in fact it isn't detrimental to your overall role in society.
Works Cited
G. (n.d.).
Understanding Gender. Retrieved March 30, 2014, from https://www.genderspectrum.org/understanding-gender
Mayer, N.
(2009, May 19). How I Met Your Mother: Stereotyping Society? Retrieved from http://voices.yahoo.com/how-met-mother-stereotyping-society-3304402.html?cat=39
Cobb, R. A., Walsh, C. E., & Priest, J. B. (2009). The Cognitive-Active Gender Role
Identification Continuum. Journal Of Feminist Family Therapy, 21(2),
77-97. doi:10.1080/08952830902911339
This is an interesting take on Ted. I have seen a ton of the episodes and personally never thought of him as acting feminine, I just thought he was annoying. I think I am guilty for criticizing his femininity because I chose to just not like him as an actor or character when I watched the show. With his high voice and animated demeanor, I never thought of him as feminine, I just thought he over did it and acted too hard. This paper has definitely given me more appreciation for the show. I do think its good that he pushes the gender norms. I always thought of him as being desperate though and not feminine. I like that you presented him as a balanced character and that he is the first really to be like this on TV. Ted does represent a romantic side that not many guys like to admit which always made me like him more.
ReplyDelete